How the Economic Machine Works ? – Ray Dalio
The economy is like a machine. At the most fundamental level it is a relatively simple machine. But many people
don’t understand it – or they don’t agree on how it works – and this has led to a lot of needless economic
How the Economic Machine Works: “A Transactions-Based Approach”
A sum of transaction is what builds the economy. Transactions are in human nature that creates three main forces that drive the economy.
2. Short Term Debt Cycles
3. Long Term Debt Cycles
An economy is simply the sum of the transactions that make it up. A transaction is a simple thing. Because there
are a lot of them, the economy looks more complex than it really is. If instead of looking at it from the top down,
we look at it from the transaction up, it is much easier to understand.
A transaction consists of the buyer giving money (or credit) to a seller and the seller giving a good, a service or a
financial asset to the buyer in exchange.
A market consists of all the buyers and sellers making exchanges for
the same things – e.g., the wheat market consists of different people making different transactions for different
reasons over time. An economy consists of all of the transactions in all of its markets. So, while seemingly
complex, an economy is really just a zillion simple things working together, which makes it look more complex
than it really is.
For any market, or for any economy, if you know the total amount of money (or credit) spent and the total
quantity sold, you know everything you need to know to understand it.
For example, since the price of any good,
service or financial asset equals the total amount spent by buyers (total $) divided by the total quantity sold by
sellers (total Quantity), in order to understand or forecast the price of anything you just need to forecast total $ and total
Quantity. While in any market there are lots of buyers and sellers, and these buyers and sellers have different
motivations, the motivations of the most important buyers are usually pretty understandable and adding them up
to understand the economy isn’t all that tough if one builds from the transactions up. This perspective of supply and demand is different from the traditional
perspective in which both supply and demand are measured in quantity and the price relationship between them
is described in terms of elasticity. This difference has important implications for understanding markets.
Productivity matters the most in long term and not short
term unlike debt , thus change in cycle is not due to much creativity or
innovation there is but due to credit being availed. When there is excess money in market the central bank lifts
the interest rate to control inflation phase
– deflation phase.This cycle continues for 5-8 years , but each time it occurs
it ends up with more growth and debt.
Productivity growth is ultimately what matters for long-term prosperity, and the effects of debt cycles cancel out over time, the swings around that productivity long-term trend arising from debt cycles cancel out over such long amounts of time (upwards of 100 years because of long-term debt cycles) that it is impossible to look at growth periods without debt cycles playing a role in driving the outcomes. Of course, when one lengthens the observed time frame, the shorter-term volatility that is due to debt swings diminishes in importance. Lets dwell deep in the concept , to understand it better.
matters most in the short run. Productivity growth tends to be linear. As we
age, we become more productive. And as the economy as a whole ages, it becomes
more productive too. It’s the use of credit that leads to economic cycles. Debt
allows us to consume more than we produce when we acquire it, but forces us to
consume less than we produce when we pay it back. When we use credit, we’re
borrowing from our future selves.
Short Term Volatility
Short-term volatility is more due to debt cycles than productivity, but this volatility cancels out over
time because credit allows people to consume more than they produce when they acquire it, and it forces people
to consume less than they produce when they pay it back. Undulations around long-term productivity are driven
by debt cycles.
Remember, in an economy without credit, the only way to increase your spending is to produce
more, but in an economy with credit, you can also increase your spending by borrowing. That creates cycles.
When debt levels are low relative to income levels and are rising, the upward cycle is self-reinforcing on the
upside because rising spending generates rising incomes and rising net worth, which raise borrowers’ capacity to
borrow, which allows more buying and spending, etc.
However, since debts can’t rise faster than money and
income forever, there are limits to debt growth.
Think of debt growth that is faster than income growth as being like air in a scuba bottle there is a limited
amount of it that you can use to get an extra boost, but you can’t live on it forever. In the case of debt, you can
take it out before you put it in (i.e., if you don’t have any debt, you can take it out), but you are expected to return
what you took out. When you are taking it out, you can spend more than is sustainable, which will give you the
appearance of being prosperous. At such times, you and those who are lending to you might mistake you as being creditworthy and not pay enough attention to what paying back will look like. When debts can no longer
be raised relative to incomes and the time for paying back comes, the process works in reverse.
The concepts of how productivity and indebtedness affect growth, then fleshed these forces out with specific
indicators, and then saw how the formula created this way worked. This approach because its believe
that one should be able to describe the cause-effect relationships and the logic behind them without looking at
the data and that only after doing that should one look at the data to see how well the descriptions square with
what happened because otherwise one would be inclined to be blinded by data and not force oneself to
objectively test one’s understanding of the cause-effect relationships.
As mentioned, from what I can tell, about two-thirds of a country’s 10-year growth rates will be due to
productivity and about one-third will be due to indebtedness. The visual below conveys these two forces. Our
productivity indicators aim to measure how steep the productivity growth line will be over time, and our
indebtedness measures aim to measure how debt cycles will influence growth over the medium term.
How the Market-Based System Works
As mentioned, the previously outlined economic players buy and sell both:
1) goods and services 2) financial
assets, and they can pay for them with either 1) money or 2) credit. In a market-based system, this exchange
takes place through free choice i.e., there are “free markets” in which buyers and sellers of goods, services and
financial assets make their transactions in pursuit of their own interests.
The production and purchases of
financial assets (i.e., lending and investing) is called “capital formation”. It occurs because both the buyer and
seller of these financial assets believe that the transaction is good for them. Those with money and credit provide
it to recipients in exchange for the recipients’ “promises” to pay them more. So, for this process to work well,
there must be large numbers of capable providers of capital (i.e., investors/lenders) who choose to give money
and credit to large numbers of capable recipients of capital (borrowers and sellers of equity) in exchange for the
recipients’ believable claims that they will return amounts of money and credit that are worth more than they
were given. While the amount of money in existence is controlled by central banks, the amount of credit in
existence can be created out of thin air i.e., any two willing parties can agree to do a transaction on credit –
though this is influenced by central bank policies.
In bubbles more credit is created than can be later paid back,
which creates busts.
When capital contractions occur, economic contractions also occur, i.e., there is not enough money and/or credit
spent on goods, services and financial assets. These contractions typically occur for two reasons, which are most
commonly known as recessions (which are contractions within a short-term debt cycle) and depressions (which
are contractions within deleveraging).
Recessions are typically well understood because they happen often and
most of us have experienced them, whereas depressions and deleveraging are typically poorly understood
because they happen infrequently and are not widely experienced.
A short-term debt cycle, (which is commonly called the business cycle), arises from a) the rate of growth in
spending (i.e., total $ funded by the rates of growth in money and credit) being faster than the rate of growth in
the capacity to produce (i.e., total Q) leading to price (P) increases until b) the rate of growth in spending is
curtailed by tight money and credit, at which time a recession occurs. In other words, a recession is an economic
contraction that is due to a contraction in private sector debt growth arising from tight central bank policy
(usually to fight inflation), which ends when the central bank eases.
Recessions end when central banks lower
interest rates to stimulate demand for goods and services and the credit growth that finances these purchases,
because lower interest rates 1) reduce debt service costs; 2) lower monthly payments of
items bought on credit, which stimulates the demand for them; and 3) raise the prices of income-producing
assets like stocks, bonds and real estate through the present value effect of discounting their expected cash flows
at the lower interest rates, producing a “wealth effect” on spending.
Long Term Debt Cycles
A long-term debt cycle, arises from debts rising faster than both incomes and money until this can’t continue
because debt service costs become excessive, typically because interest rates can’t be reduced any more. A
deleveraging is the process of reducing debt burdens (i.e., debt and debt service relative to incomes).
Deleveraging typically is mix of
1) Debt reduction
3) Redistribution of wealth
4) Debt monetization.
A depression is the economic contraction phase of a deleveraging. It occurs because the
contraction in private sector debt cannot be rectified by the central bank lowering the cost of money. In
depressions, a) a large number of debtors have obligations to deliver more money than they have to meet their
obligations, and b) monetary policy is ineffective in reducing debt service costs and stimulating credit growth.
Typically, monetary policy is ineffective in stimulating credit growth either because interest rates can’t be
lowered (because interest rates are near 0%) to the point of favorably influencing the economics of spending and
capital formation (this produces deflationary deleveraging), or because money growth goes into the purchase of
inflation-hedge assets rather than into credit growth, which produces inflationary deleveraging.
typically ended by central banks printing money to monetize debt in amounts that offset the deflationary
depression effects of debt reductions and austerity.
To be clear, while depressions are the contraction phase of a deleveraging, deleveraging (e.g., reducing debt
burdens) can occur without depressions if they are well managed. (See ”An In-Depth Look at Deleveraging.“)
Differences in how governments behave in recessions and deleveraging are good clues that signal which one is
For example, in deleveraging, central banks typically ”print“ money that they use to buy large
quantities of financial assets in order to compensate for the decline in private sector credit, while these actions
are unheard of in recessions.4
Also, in deleveraging, central governments typically spend much, much more to
make up for the fall in private sector spending.
But let‘s not get ahead of ourselves. Since these two types of contractions are just parts of two different types of
cycles that are explained more completely in this Template, let’s look at the Template.
My Key Learning from Ray Dalio’s Presentation:
faster than income.
for goods that keeps raising the price- keeping the debt and income equation
due to high debt repayment , thus the inevitable chain or spending and earnings
continue reaching a long term debt peak.
disappear , asset prices drop,social tensions rise , leaving no one
creditworthy. The borrowers can no more take money to repay their previous
loans , they rush to sell assets results in lower prices -lower stock market. This
looks like deflation, but the difference here is the interest cannot be fiddled
with because interest rates are already
0%(USA-1930’s & 2008) and lenders realized that the money they gave would
never come back since the borrowers have lost ability to pay and their
collateral has lost value. Thus like an individual, the economy itself is not
, the income fall faster than debt being repaid This leads us to the next step i.e borrowing
is being reduced , but the bank has
given loans to people who would not be able recover, thus people rush to
withdraw , bank thus squeezes and default on their debt. This is now become a
DEPRESSION – realization when people
thought much of their wealth they had was a not real . this means that what the
bank considered their asset (our collateral ) is not worth anything , thus many
bank settle for debt restructuring, but is still a problem since the assets
have no value- no income.
give allowance for high unemployment and some goods and services. They spend
more then they earn- this is what you hear ‘fiscal deficit’.
and lenders, but who would it lend from? ‘The richies’. Social disorder and
revolt breaks out – within the country or between two different country,
leading to political change that can be extreme(hitler coming to power).
bonds of central government.
there is Quantitative Easing , but not really if its only debt repayment. The equation to
remember is that spending(cash+credit)/quantity is what sets the price – so the
credit disappears and the money printed replaces it. To control this the income
growth needs to be quicker then that of the interest rate.
, if balanced then starts the re-leveraging in the economy.
Increase your productivity.