Is Value Investing Dead in India?

Reading Time: 4 minutes

Source linkLinkedIn Profile | Twitter Profile


‘Our Recent Performance Sucks.’ Here’s Your $10 Billion Back.

This was recently quoted as a headline to a WSJ article citing the closure of AJO Partners, a boutique value-investing firm founded by Ted Aronson which once had USD 30 bn as Assets Under Management (AUM) at the 2007 peak.

So what made AJO partners shut their fund?

Short answer – Under-performance coupled with the biggest client pulling their money out (USD 500 mn in ticket size.)

Let’s back up a little bit here.

What is value investing?

Value Investing is the practice of buying an asset ‘cheap’ and selling it when it becomes ‘expensive’. This often begs the question – What is cheap? and What is expensive?

Well, for starters we will not talk about PE ratio today.


Mr. Sanjoy Bhattacharyya is a lesser-known individual who’s talked about in the investing circles in this country. His thoughts are often free-flowing and filled with a lot of wisdom.

This is precisely the reason we will try to objectively filter Value Investing from his lens from a talk he almost gave 10 years ago!

Watch it below:

Buying a Great Business at a Great Price

Price is what you pay, value is what you get.

Warren Buffett

Sanjoy argues that the right price is very important to identify the first step in value investing.

Also Read on FinMedium:  How to Gift Shares Online using Zerodha

But this great price should belong to a ‘great’ business.

There’s no point trying to find a ‘great’ price to a ‘bad’ or a ‘gruesome’ business.

Bad or Gruesome businesses are often the ones that end up either burning a lot of money or need constant capital infusions to keep earning money or simply, stay afloat. More on this, later.

Stock Market – Works against the basic principle of economics

The stock market is a funny place when one tries to look at it from the lens of the basic principle of economics.

Lower the price, higher the demand, and vice-versa?

The markets seem to work contrary to this basic principle.

Often you’ll see when prices are climbing, the demand for the stock rises. The opposite is often true when the price drops and it is often coupled with incessant selling.

Why does this happen?


Optimism is the biggest enemy for a value investor.

Is Value Investing Dead in India?

Importance of Price

Speculation and Investing are two different things.

Graham was very objective when he defined what Investing is

“An operation upon which thorough analysis promises safety of principle & a satisfactory return.”

Notice how satisfactory return is secondary. The primary objective in value investing is safety of the principal.

This makes the importance of price very paramount.

One should try and objectively understand the worth of the business. Do not try to look at the price of the stock but the worth of the whole company to realize what is it worth.

Also Read on FinMedium:  Delta Corp Stock Analysis

What about Markets?

What most people often fail to understand is the fact that markets are not efficient all the time. They are efficient most of the time.

While in today’s day and age we can all argue that information is being processed at lightning speed and all trades are being done by algo bots, it is important to understand that while information is available all the time – processing is still done by the human brain.

The human mind is filled with multiple emotions that make it act in different ways a lot of times.

What to avoid?


The only way to go broke is – GREED.

Concluding Thoughts

Sanjoy argues that the only way to make stupendous wealth by value investing is to make a significant bet on the point of maximum pessimism.

At the point of maximum pessimism, the margin of safety is higher because the price is, in all probability at the ‘right range’.

This will also prevent you from the shackles of trying to sell smart because there is a reasonable margin of safety.

This finally begs the question.

Is value investing dead?

I was ending this post very comfortably at 3:45 AM when professor Damodaran dropped a truth bomb.

I have a love-hate relationship with value investing. I believe in value, but I don’t much care for the rigidity and righteousness with which some value investors approach investing. I have three posts on the topic that may enrage you, but it is time for some soul searching.

Also Read on FinMedium:  Astec Lifesciences Ltd - Company Analysis


Value Investing I: The allure of value investing as a philosophy comes from its one-two punch, with stories of great value investors (Graham to Buffett) backed up by data (low PE/low PBV outperformed high PE/PBV by wide margins) from the last century.



Value Investing II: The glory days of value investing were not that glorious, with little evidence of payoff to active value investing, but the last decade was devastating, as even value investing legends lost their mojo. COVID has made it worse:



Value Investing III: While some in value investing view the last decade as a passing phase, and many blame the Fed, value investing needs to change to find its place again. I don’t have the answers, but I do have some suggestions:


Read more Research Reports on Indian Companies here.

Source linkLinkedIn Profile | Twitter Profile

Cover Image: Quartz

Every Wednesday and Saturday, we send Info-Graphic and FinMedium Weekly Digest newsletters to our 25000+ Subscribers.

Join Them Now!

Saket Mehrotra

Saket Mehrotra

Saket is a number cruncher, avid reader, coffee connoisseur, book store hopper & Metallica fan. He is an active follower of Sensex since 2009. CA, CS by profession.
Please Share :)